John & Tony's Pizzeria

1109 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10065 Order now
Hero image

Quality Pies on the Upper East Side


Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

John & Tony's Pizzeria Reviews on Grubhub


Top Reviewer
Years ago I used to get pizza from John and Tony's and it was terrific. This is the first time in almost 30 years I've ordered from them and the pizza is still fantastic. The calzones are very tasty. It's always nice to know somethings remain the same.


2 reviews
Wow! The hawaiian pizza got to me in just 18 minutes after I ordered! I live only two blocks away, but that is still super fast. I love John and Tony's!!!


1 review
This was delicious pizza. Some of the best I have ever had! We enjoyed it!


1 review
SO delicious. The basil and mozzarella pizza was so good.


1 review
Very prompt. Very good pizza. Decent prices for Manhattan.

Reviews from

John & Tony's Pizzeria Reviews on Seamless


Top Reviewer
I've never written a seamless review, but I will for John and Tony's. These guys are everything you could ask for. Food was exactly on time, hot, delicious, and MORE than expected. Keep this up and you'll be my new go to on the UES anytime I crave Italian. They might be new, but they know exactly what they're doing. These guys blew everyone else out of the water.


Top Reviewer
Had some issues with seamless and their preorder policies but John & Tony's held it down and made 65 middle schoolers VERY happy. They were communicative and they managed to make 20 pizzas in record time.

Thank you for everything, I will be ordering again for my next pizza party event!


Top Reviewer
I order from here a couple times a week. Just classic pastas and pizzas. I love the spaghetti Bolognese and spaghetti puttanesca. Huge portions. Soooooo goood


Top Reviewer
The sauce tastes like real sauce not like others coming from a can or jar. You can sense the flavors of garlic, chunky tomatoes and basil. Very good.


Top Reviewer
I am so disgusted by a lot of pizza places. Poor quality. No care. However, this place is great. Food tastes fresh and full of flavor. Fast delivery.

About us

Dinner, Late Night, Lunch Specials, Pizza
Delivery: 10:00 AM - 5:00 AM
Takeout: 10:00 AM - 5:00 AM